- USA Today pans HBO’s “A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms” as dull and listless, with shallow characters and shock content that can’t mask weak storytelling.
- The six-episode, ~30-minute format signals a lower-scope, likely cost-saving pivot that may reduce audience investment versus prior Westeros epics.
- “House of the Dragon” remains large (about 25M viewers per Season 2 episode) but is down from Season 1, highlighting softer franchise momentum.
- The combination of weaker reviews and shifting viewing patterns raises risks of brand fatigue and pressured ROI for future “Game of Thrones” extensions.
Read More
As an investment banking managing director assessing franchise strategy and media economics, it’s crucial to gauge the risk-return of recent “Game of Thrones” spin-offs in light of audience behaviour, production costs, and brand value. The new USA Today review of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms underscores severe shortcomings: despite working from the proven IP of George R.R. Martin’s Dunk and Egg novellas, the spin-off is slammed for being “halfhearted and listless,” with a protagonist described as a “hollow shell,” and cheap shocks (bodily fluid imagery, explicit nudity) failing to compensate for superficial characters and dull pacing.
Strategically, HBO’s choice to produce “Knight” as a smaller-scale, six-episode season with ∼30-minute episodes marks a sharp pivot from the format of its predecessors. Traditionally, successful fantasy franchises have depended on long arcs, high production budgets, and spectacle (e.g., dragons, battles). Reducing episode count and length can lower cost exposure—but also limits audience investment and perceived value. Early leaks suggest fans are underwhelmed with this shift.
Examining “House of the Dragon” performance offers a relevant comparator. It debuted to almost 10 million viewers across linear and streaming platforms in August 2022—the largest HBO launch ever for a new original series. Over time, though, its Season 2 premiere saw a 22% drop from its own debut. The season averaged around 25 million viewers per episode, down from ~29 million in Season 1. While its Season 2 finale (8.9 million viewers Sunday night) showed growth relative to its Season 2 premiere (7.8 million) it still failed to match key benchmarks set earlier.
This trajectory suggests that while brand power carries spin-offs to initial viewership peaks, keeping momentum depends on quality and format. If “Knight” fails critically, HBO risks diluting its fantasy portfolio at a time when competitors are pulling back or reinventing. The decline in linear viewing also indicates changing consumption habits, raising pressure on streaming metrics and long-tail engagement.
From an investment perspective, the opportunity cost of allowing franchise fatigue is significant. Expensive productions with weak returns can drag on margin, and brands that fail to evolve risk losing their premium positioning. On the flip side, lower-cost experiments could be part of a diversified strategy if carefully calibrated: letting studios test new formats (shorter seasons, less spectacle) with leaner budgets, keeping great content high-faithful to source material, and keeping communication with audiences strong.
Open questions: How will “Knight”’s shorter and less spectacular format affect churn or subscription retention? What is the production budget per episode vs. expected revenue streams? Will the critical panning impact international sales/licensing or merchandising? Might HBO need to reimagine what “premium fantasy” means without relying on dragons and grand battles?
Supporting Notes
- “Knight” is described in USA Today as “torturous and drab,” prioritizing disgust and shock (projectile defecation, graphic sexual content) over storytelling or character development.
- S1 vs S2 of “House of the Dragon”: S2 premiere drew 7.8 million viewers, down roughly 22% from S1’s 10 million launch.
- S2 finale of “House of the Dragon” reached 8.9 million viewers—the best of S2—but still below S1 finale (9.3 million).
- “Knight” will consist of six ~30-minute episodes, marking a departure from hour-long runtimes of past Westeros entries.
- HBO concedes that linear viewership—TV channel broadcasts—is declining, while streaming days are being used to bolster “House of the Dragon’s” totals.
- Critic’s verdict: Dunk is “a hollow shell,” Egg fills “twee, precocious tropes,” supporting characters “skin-deep.”