- Wall Street’s 2024 bonus pool hit a record $47.5bn, lifting the New York securities-industry average bonus to about $244,700.
- The gains were uneven, with many mid-level staff seeing sharp cuts, deferrals, or token payouts while top rainmakers were protected.
- Bonus outcomes hinge on individual production, business-line results, and internal politics, and firms often avoid true “zero bonuses” by using informal floors to limit legal and reputational risk.
- Early, clear manager feedback helps staff judge whether a low bonus is a one-off setback or a signal to reset expectations or move.
Read More
The substantial bonus gains across Wall Street for 2024 masked deeply uneven outcomes. While aggregate data show record pools and per-employee averages, the distribution is highly skewed: rainmakers and top senior roles benefit most, while many mid-level bankers endure steep reductions, deferrals, or even symbolic bonuses. The cases where individuals receive no bonus—or just a fraction—highlight the existence of both unofficial compensation floors and significant latitude in management discretion.
Factors driving bonus cuts mirror those discussed in the FT article. Underperforming business lines, disappointing personal production, or reputational missteps are cited. Even when firm profits and deal flow soar, certain teams or individuals may be penalized, especially if they lack strong internal networks. Firms also tend to insulate long-standing and visible seniors from cuts, pushing reduction burdens onto lower roles.
From an employment relations and legal risk standpoint, the practice of maintaining a modest minimum bonus (often around 15% of the prior year’s bonus) illustrates concern over implied contracts or reputational damage. A “zero bonus” is rare and potentially contested, so firms often ensure minimal acknowledgment of poor performance rather than silence [inspiration].
Strategically, such bonus cycles affect retention, morale, and long-term investment in talent. A sharp cut sets a lower baseline for future years, making recovery difficult. Without transparent communication, individuals may misinterpret whether their future at the firm is secure. For managers, early signaling, explicit acknowledgments, and mapping paths to recovery are tools to mitigate talent loss or disengagement.
Looking ahead, caution is warranted: though Wall Street saw record bonus totals in 2024, forecasts for 2025 and beyond point to more restrained increases. Consultants predict 2025 bonuses in many sectors growing only modestly—or even declining—due to regulatory uncertainty, weak lending, and slowing deal flow. These dynamics are likely to amplify the distributional effects and increase political sensitivity around compensation.
Supporting Notes
- The total 2024 bonus pool in New York′s securities industry reached US$47.5 billion, up about 32-34% from the previous year, with average per-employee bonuses rising to ≈US$244,700.
- Wall Street bonus growth in 2024 followed a profit jump of about 90% for securities firms, driven by gains in dealmaking, trading, and debt issuance.
- Citi’s transformation bonus plan for senior bankers paid out only about 53% of target in 2024, versus 94% in 2022—despite improving financial performance—due to regulatory and control-related shortfalls.
- Sectoral forecasts from Johnson Associates show: equity sales & trading bonus increases in 2025 of 15-25%; advisory and equity underwriting up 10-15%; fixed income and debt underwriting up between 5-15%; whereas commercial/retail banking bonuses may dip 5-10%.
- Practices in investment banking include informal floors (≈15% of the prior year’s bonus), seldom paying literally zero bonus to avoid legal/reputational risk [inspiration].
- Managers engaging earlier through performance reviews (6-8 weeks beforehand), clarifying whether a low bonus is temporary or indicates change in long-term value, help prevent misunderstandings and career damage [inspiration].